Hive and the people here can be quite effective once they put their abilities together to come up with something and agree to get it done. This post isn't going to discuss the commentrewarder idea as the creation of it is being tended to by @hivetrending.
But since the rewards only go out first after a post pays out, I wanted to already give it a try and check something else with this post.
General activity by users.
Simply if you're reading this, let me know in a comment that you're here!
I'll vote the comment up and after 7 days you will then get a share of the post rewards of this post as a tip on your comment.
Again, not going to go into more details about the project as we'll await the dev to announce its release so I appreciate if your comments wouldn't be about it!
Let me know if you're still active on hive and reading this by leaving a comment!
I'll post about the reason to this post a bit later!
Please reblog this post to get it to as many as possible, I'll also be self-voting it in this case for the attention as the post rewards will go fully to comments below, thanks!
PS. A pic of Mew for the banner of this post!
Never left 😊
Hijacking this top comment with a reply since many asked for more of Mew.
Here's a short where he's involved :D
Incentivized engagement!
self-voting this comment to test @commentrewarder (should burn tips on self-votes)
I'm here!
Been here for 8 years and 3 months. Posting a bit, commenting and replying, up voting most of the replies to me in order to give a tiny reward for engagement.
I read almost all of your posts because I am interested in what you do, specifically holozing lately. I have some ZING staked and in the pool as well. Looking forward to the future of your game. Not sure if its my kind of game since I like something more chill and leisurely like dCrops and pepegame. But I am setting myself up with a supply of tokens in case I do decide to jump in hard!
Back to the topic of comment rewarding, I'm experimenting with that on @tokenfaucet and @gamefaucet. The reward is not from the reward pool, I just give away a small amount of my own tokens. The posts do get a few up votes, but I don't take the post rewards out, I'll give them away eventually. I'm not trying to reward meaningful comments with these accounts, but I believe I'm making people feel good about being on Hive with that little shot of dopamine for getting a random free gift.
All the best to you and holozing and hivetrending and commentrewarder!
I knew this would come in handy one day
lol nice
It's up and running already...? That's so cool. Kudos @hivetrending (I believe you're also doing some work on user retention and now on user engagement too). 👏👏👏👏
I feel like this @commentrewarder initiative will branch out to more use cases, and I want to see how the community will think beyond its current application. For sure, I'll be using it too! 🤩
We've been working on it for several days.
I worry that the tools I help build are not used very much and that the hours invested go to waste. Everything has an opportunity cost. The time spent at the keyboard could instead be spent outdoors or with close friends.
Building on Hive, I feel hopeful. Each new project builds on the learnings of the previous ones, and the relationships strengthen as well.
So, you can help me greatly by using these tools, and spreading the word!
We need more engagement and retention here. Whatever encourages genuine connection and enjoyment of the platform is not a waste. I'm not familiar with the details of your project, but I am curious. Thank you so much for doing what you can to make this wonderful place even better 🙌
True. It may not make sense right away for someone to give out a portion of their rewards to their commenters, but I feel like it will become useful, especially for posters who are looking for more feedback on their content.
I'm definitely going to use it and will also assist in promoting it. Hopefully, it will turn out well.
Most people want engagement and many don't even care about the rewards much, they use hive cause it's easier to be seen here compared to the big socials. Most of those people would also like to reward the commenters but since price is low and not everyone has that much HP to get comments past the minimum threshold they can instead forfeit part of their post rewards, curators can then maybe give them a slightly bigger vote instead, etc. People shouldn't see it as a way to "lose rewards" when giving a small % of post rewards to commenters, majority of voting power is used on posts anyway.
This is what got me interested in Ecency, Pizza, Pimp, and other second layer tokens. I love rewarding good comments, even if it's just a small thing, barely monetary. It lets people know their interaction is appreciated
Not yet, but I'm hoping it will be before 7 days (or that this post is forced in later if delays occur :D)
I see. I've noted that. I was thinking of testing it out.😅
Looking forward to the announcement.
test at your own risk for now 😁
I will do that (a nice little % for now). I'll also give a quick hint about it in my post to see how it turns out.
No idea what this is about but - I’m here, I’m reading your posts - mostly, and I want to know what’s going on.
Also, I love Mew- such a chomp!
Such a nice photograph of Mew 😎🖤
thanks I'm getting pretty good at taking pics! 😘
I love cats so much, that picture got me here immediately 😍!
I haven't been around for limg time, but it's time to come back definitely. 🫶
That's fantastic. It's awesome that someone is turning your idea into a reality. Kudos to @hivetrending 😉
I'm here for the cats 😀
This photo is strongly meme-licious 😁
😀
waaaaaa cutieeeeee mew
#iamalive
Hive has literally saved my bacon more than once. I'm a long time hodlr, but there were occasions when I had to lean on the power of Hive to push me through. What a great platform and community 👏
Awesome to hear!
Can't wait to see how this will work. @hivetrending is a true master at this!
I am here and will continue to be!
This post got so much attention. I wish Propolis got the same :P.
Me too man me too. I was really expecting more for that project.
is that @pharesim's project?
Yes. Pharesim built a fully functioning wiki that stores all the content in Hive posts, content is viewable from any Hive front-end. The propol.is site looks decent and it has a built-in search index.
I spent a couple weeks adding some quality of life features.
Unfortunately we decided to slow down on development because there wasn’t much adoption. Not many editors showed up to contribute content to the wiki. It’a a role for volunteers, no pay.
Are the entries posts? How do potential edits from others work?
All the wiki pages are posts. The edits from others work using posting authority. Anyone can join the Discord and ask for edit permissions, and then after approval they can add Propolis.eng authorized account to Hive Keychain
https://peakd.com/@propolis.eng for English version
Hmm wondering how things could be incentivized with votes or why they shouldn't (if that's a decision by the creator and co), post rewards after payout could go to the author but leave some for future edits? Dunno. Will try looking into it more but a bit short on time atm
Commenting on the posts of other hive members is for me one of the best ways to create community, in fact a few years ago I was part of a project called @elcomentador that was in charge of leaving valuable comments, as well as to encourage commenting and curating good comments, so I think it's great that now this new proposal arises.
Definitely still here, and will now also wait on the dev release -- @hivetrending, let me know when the announcement is out, and I will spread it a little more in my Friday digest. You might also want to let some people in the Spanish and German language communities know -- I will cover that on Friday, but it is just a thought for you as well.
I'm here! Nice photo of Mew :D
This year my
winningposting streak was broken because I had to fix my computer. But I am still here. Where else would I go?3speak fucked mine up last year
That's a shame.
Still here after 7+ Years and never left.
I guess this one could break the record of the post with the most comments on Hive. Something else that is needed one way or another is for accounts to get a score that measures contribution. It's crazy how many accounts there are who know how to play the game and get big upvotes from the curation programs without any intention to power up while just cashing out everything they earn. If comments are going to get rewarded more it likely will come with a flood of these users who only want to take. If somehow the contribution score is a deciding factor if their comments actually can get upvoted, it would give an actual incentive to power up and curate instead of just using Hive as a milking cow which keeps the price low.
Guess it's up to the authors to curate the comments properly.
This same argument can be made for the Curation Programs on Hive.
Just do the test, go to a random Daily Post from one of them were all the 'good quality posts' that got curated are lined up. Click on one of those posts, go to the wallet of that user. 8 out of 10 times, you will see limited to no investment and at least 1 cashout in the last weeks.
I'm not hating on anyone, certain content, or saying nobody can't cash out earnings. It's just that this dynamic of many users knowing how to make a post look good for them to get upvoted by the curation programs, and these curation programs mainly have these users on their radar as it's easy work to upvote something that looks ok. All this while there is a total disregard toward actual contributions (let's be honest, 99% of content doesn't really contribute) as everyone is just dumping Hive even at current price without any intentions to build their account and give something back.
All I'm saying is that having some kind of easy-to-check score that shows if a user helps or hurts the Hive Ecosystem without making it a witch hunt would help a lot.
I'm sure it's something people lay notice/judge whether they want to or not, we're people after all sharing the same token in the same ecosystem. I'm just hoping when new users arrive a % of them see the value in longterm holding and "dilute" out the constant dumpers.
I'm here!
A salute to Mew. He seems not in the mood hehe. Or maybe he doesn't like photos like my Milo 😺
I'm here!
Always attentive 🙋🏽♀️
Receiving visitors.
aws!
I'm here, and I've been active for two years now trying my best to leave a feedback on post I find quite interesting. This post brings good tidings and I really love it.
Good morning, I'm here for a while and still active.
Have a nice Sunday
!ALIVE
!LOLZ
lolztoken.com
Nothing. It just let out a little wine.
Credit: reddit
$LOLZ on behalf of dailyspam
(1/6)
Farm LOLZ tokens when you Delegate Hive or Hive Tokens.
Click to delegate: 10 - 20 - 50 - 100 HP@acidyo, I sent you an
Alive and kicking!
I also have an idea to improve comment rewards by the way. I've been trying to contact you on Discord about it.
responded now ^^
Of course we are active here on Hive, friend, as always, and an important part for me is the interaction that can be achieved thanks to the comments. I also think that this way we all gain a little more, that's for sure.
I am here from the last 7 years and will continue be here till this chain is alive
Here I am to read.
I have been here for 7 years.
I finished to read this post.
Hii!
Hello from 🇨🇺.
This might be something we use for our posts.
I'm still here. The idea of shared rewards to promote engagement is interesting. I like it!
Believe it or not, I'm always here!
I believe it!
I'm still here. Just been pretty busy with life stuff. I wanna get back into sharing some cool animations on the platform though. But we'll see.
Although I often read posts, I don't always leave comments. Sometimes I just don't have an unambiguous or competent enough opinion, but I don't want to write something like a "good post". Or I communicate with the same people in messengers. Maybe I'm wrong. But whatever it was, the cat is just charming!)
Thanks! 😸
I'm around :-)
The attention you're getting is impressive! It would be great to leverage Hive crowd-sourcing for those small but crucial tasks that could help draw even more attention to our efforts.
Yep, I still (apparently ... 😉) check my feed, pretty consistently. So ... Here you go. My latest POL comment ...
I don't write posts anymore but I often check what's going on on hive. It's always nice to come back and read, I have very nice memories about the platform and the people I met here :)
Hey mate, nice to see you after so long! How's the family?
Hope to see u active again soon!
Hey @acidyo I am active on Hive and reading your post. This is all very intriguing and I am looking forward to see where all this is leading. I hope my small little contribution here has helped you in some way.
I reckon this cat knows more about what's going on than the rest of us! Or is that a clue?
Haha the cat is just a banner as people tend to not like posts without an image around here. :D
So you're the creator of @ocd! Where the hell have you been? Have you seen the quality and quantity of my endeavours? Man, it's a tough grind on Hive. I have never once got the attention of OCD, why do you hate me? I'm amazing. You're a tough cookie to crack I can tell you.
Joking aside can I ask you a genuine question? Is it you doing the curation manually or do you have people working on your behalf?
We have quite a team and individual community owners and their curators weighing in as well, we primarily overlook their nominations for votes and make sure the posts are in our scope.
First tip I can give taking a glance at your posts is to use communities! Second one I can give is that crypto/finance posts aren't in our scope but they are on @leofinance's and others, and there as well it would probably be easier to be seen posting in their community/through their front-end!
Hey thanks man, I really appreciate the feedback and tips. As you can see I am new in town and I am still trying to find my way. But I can see that Hive has a ton of potential and it's so nice to be part of a very innovative platform.
I really make an effort with my posts and my interests are varied, I am sure I can make a valuable contribution to Hive. Hopefully I can make some meaningful connections and get involved with a project. I can see that I also have to invest in the ecosystem and have already bought and powered up 500 Hive and will be buying another 500 Hive to power up shortly.
I have seen communities around but I was not quite sure how to use them. So I will check them out again and get involved and post from within communities. I actually don't do that many posts on crypto and I have already published a few posts via @leofinance and using the InLeo interface.
I actually had a really nice vote come through on my latest post from @empo.voter, I don't know if that was anything to do with you but if it was thanks very much.
Hehe yea that along with @empoderat trail some of my votes some times, something that's possible on here due to our feeless transactions!
Other that those tips I'd say engagement is very important early on, curators in my project at least are advised to always check if users are contributing in meaningful ways through engagement as well along with posts. I can see you already are doing that though so just keep at it!
List of communities: https://peakd.com/communities
Thanks again @acidyo, I will keep on persevering. Yes, I totally get how important it is to engage with other peoples work, it is a crucial way of getting to know people and building relationships.
Just out of interest, you say you have curators in your project, what kind of qualities do you look for in those curators and at what stage, if ever, could I be considered for applying?
If I understand correctly there will be a project to reward and incentivize those who are active and write comments? Great idea and I am curious to find out about this new project and will follow you closely
@tipu curate
Upvoted 👌 (Mana: 31/51) Liquid rewards.
I never knew you had a cat, Mew is a cutie 😻
I'm trying to think through the mechanics of how this would work.... like setting a share of beneficiary rewards or something..? Amazing what you can do with hive. Makes sense to allow people to easily incentivize engagement!
yeah beneficiary for starters, let's see what else we'll come up with!
It's a useful addition for sure!
I came here a few months ago and I am still here.
I do drop by whenever I can because we all know we have real life issues to face 🥺
So, are we trying to break any recent record here for engagement? 😀 Or maybe I'm too optimist... We'll see...
Haha doubt that, those records from 2018 are hard to beat
That's true... That's why I said recent, lol. Still pretty hard to beat.
Haha my bad, been reading too many comments lately 😁
So sorry for your eyes, but you asked for it. 😋
That meow is chillin', so cutiee!
He is very cute. 😺
Any more cat pics? Those are always welcome.
Seems like something beneficial is around the corner.
I am here, reading the post, awaiting the new implementation 🙏
I’m still active! ✌🏾
!ALIVE
!BBH
nice!
I am !ALIVE. 😀
Mew is not Amewsed
I'm here. 😁😁
yo!
Have a great days ahead.😊😊
My goal is to post ever day this year and so far I have been successful.
I look forward to the explanation.
I am here and still active.