"I probably wouldn't be a good spokesman for an electric car, because I'll still get on a private jet, and one flight on a private jet undoes all my electric-car good deeds."
- George Clooney -
A Supersonic Electric Aircraft?
Elon Musk has dropped hints about design ideas for such a craft in the past.
In a recent conversation with Joe Rogan, Elon Musk revealed some fascinating insights into the ideas that he has for a battery powered aircraft. I've compiled a partial transcript of their conversation to archive here on Steemit for ready future reference.
Supersonic Electric Aircraft - Image courtesy of Daniel Olah
Note: For reasons not clear to me, the video below may not start at precisely the right point. Please adjust the time line yourself in order to listen to the segment between about 1:15:00 and 1:20:30.
Supersonic Electric Aircraft.
The text below the video is a reasonable transcript of the electric aircraft portion of this video. Joe Rogan's dialog is in italics, and the rest is Elon Musk's.
Begin Transcript
"Now have you ever looked at planes and gone 'I can fix this?
I just don't have the time.'"
"I have a design for a plane."
"You do?"
"Yeah."
"A better design?"
"I mean probably... I think it is."
"Who have you talked to about this?"
"I've talked to friends."
"Friends?"
"Friends. And girlfriends."
"I'm your friend. You can tell me. What have you got? What's going on?"
"Well I mean, an exciting thing to do would be some sort of electric vertical take-off and landing supersonic... jet of some kind."
"Vertical take-off and landing, meaning--no need for a runway--just shoot up straight in the air, and, tschooo! Oooh! How would you do that? And they do that on some military aircraft, correct?"
"Yes. The trick is that you have to transition to level flight? And then you--the thing that you would use for vertical takeoff and landing is not suitable for high-speed flight."
"So you have two different systems? Vertical takeoff, and landing system?"
"I've thought about this quite a lot. Quite a lot. The interesting thing about an electric plane is that you want to go as high as possible. But you need a certain energy density in the battery pack, because you have to overcome gravitational potential energy.
"Once you've overcome gravitational potential energy, and you're at a high altitude, the energy you use in cruise is very low. And then you can recapture a large part of your gravitational potential energy on the way down.
"So you really don't need any kind of reserve fuel, if you will, because you have the energy of height. Gravitational potential energy. This is a lot of energy.
"So, once you can get high, you... In fact, the way to think about a plane is that it's a force balance... so the force balance... So, a plane that is not accelerating is in neutral force balance. You have the force of gravity, you have the lift force of the wings, then you've got the force of whatever thrusting device--the propeller or turbine or whatever it is--and you've got the resistance force of the air.
"Now the higher you go, the lower the air resistance is. Air density drops exponentially, but drag increases with the square, and exponential beats a square. The higher you go, the faster you'll go for the same amount of energy.
"And, at a certain altitude, you can go supersonic with less energy per mile--quite a lot less energy per mile--than an aircraft at 35000 feet, because it's just a force balance."
"I'm too stupid for this conversation."
"It makes sense, though."
"No, I'm sure it does. Now, when you think about this new idea of designing--when you have this idea about improving planes--are you gonna bring this to somebody? Do you shop this around?"
"Well, I have a lot on my plate."
"Right, that's what I'm saying. I don't know how you do what you do now, but if you keep coming up with these... It's gotta be hard to pawn these off on someone else either... 'Hey, go do a job good job with this vertical take-off and landing system that I want to implement on regular planes.'"
"The electric airplane isn't necessary right now. Electric cars are important. Solar energy is important. Stationary storage of energy is important. These things are much more important than creating an electric supersonic VTOL.
"Also, the planes, naturally, you really want that gravitational energy density for an aircraft, and this is improving over time.
"So, it's important that we accelerate the transition to sustainable energy. That's why electric cars--it matters whether electric cars happen sooner or later. We're really playing a crazy game here with the atmosphere and the oceans.
"Yeah."
"We're taking vast amounts of carbon from deep underground and putting this--putting this in the atmosphere. This is crazy. We should not do this. It's very dangerous. We should accelerate the transition to sustainable energy."
"I mean the bizarre thing is that obviously we’re going to run out of oil in the long term. There’s only so much oil we can mine and burn. That’s totally logical, we must have a sustainable energy transport and energy infrastructure in the long term. So we know that’s the end point, we know that. So why run this crazy experiment where we take trillions of tons of carbon from underground and put it in the atmosphere and oceans. This is an insane experiment. It’s the dumbest experiment in human history. Why are we doing this? It’s crazy.”
End Transcript
I was frustrated that the topic of conversation changed drastically at that point, right when the aircraft discussion was starting to get interesting.
Could we clone Musk? I really want my very own personal, electric, VTOL, supersonic gad about. Really badly. I want it!
I've written a story about it here:
"Free to Move About The World"
I have another article in the works for publication on Steemit later. When I get time to complete that article, I hope to discuss some of Musk's electric aircraft ideas further.
~FIN~
you can still reward it: CLICK HERE.
The payout window never closes... CLICK WINDOW ABOVE.
Image courtesy of Teun van der Lugt
P.S. If you have an "in" with anybody at Steemit, Inc. - Would you please ask them to get rid of these damn, extremely annoying "off-website" arrow/boxes? The have, overnight, made Steemit ugly. There are much better solutions.
For more technology articles,
please check out our Library Technology Shelf - CLICK below:
Introducing: The SILVERengines proton
CONTACT US - Will Exchange for Steem - Image by @creatr
You are why I'm here on Steemit!
I have very eclectic interests and hope, over time, to write about them all.
CLICK Each Image Below⬇️⬇️To Check Out @creatr's World⬇️
|
|
|
Man...that would be awesome in theory. Not much of a science geek but wish he'd get funding to begin design
I don't think it's funding... He doesn't have the time or motivation to work on this particular idea. :(
Elon Musk such a great revolution man
He can do anything .............!!
I love it. It's my hero my inspiration
He is pretty fun to watch. There seem to be a lot of folk out there who bash the man, but overall, I admire him and what he is trying to do.
well certainly interesting even if u have light speed craft a nice airplane right sometimes is fun i hungout on a airplane with a being who has such a craft last night was quite a chat!
I would have enjoyed hearing that conversation...
I am listening to the video as I write. This would be so revolutionary to aircraft. We live in exciting times as we travel forward. Thanks my friend @creatr.
Pretty fascinating stuff, eh? :D
This is fascinating, @creatr! I agree with Elon about “this crazy experiment” we are performing — taking trillions of tons of carbon from underground and putting them into the atmosphere and oceans. Thank goodness he is thinking innovatively and has developed some clout. The battery powered airplane is a very cool idea.
Essentially, I want the liberty to travel anywhere globally in my own private craft... That is what excites me about this more than anything else, and why I wrote this story. There are some other interesting real-world electric aircraft developments already in progress, but none as yet that reach for the scope Musk speaks of here.
While I am certainly in general agreement that we need to be better stewards of the planet, I need to study the numbers and the whole "global warming" thing before I get to the alarmist stage about climate change. I am no fan of big oil, but my general viewpoint is that carbon in the air is more of a health problem (CO and other chemical compound byproducts) than a global climate change problem.
I don’t blame you one bit for wanting a private craft and the freedom to travel wherever you want, anytime. What could be more fun than that?
I grew up on science fiction and The Wonderful World of Disney and I've felt cheated out of my future.
The future has not unfolded as I had expected as a child; but it is exciting now to see some of these promises on the threshold of fulfillment. :D
Congratulations, your post had been chosen by curators of eSteem Encouragement program. Feel free to join and reach us via Discord channel if you have any questions or would like to contribute.
Thank you for using eSteem
Thank you!