On 7 September 2021, El Salvador made history as the first nation to recognise Bitcoin as legal tender.
I posted about this and its global legal implications on Hive.
[Source: Created by me using Grok with this instruction "Draw image of El Salvador dropping BTC as legal tender under IMF pressure"]
El Salvador is to make payments by BTC voluntary and taxes must be paid in USD not Bitcoin. These changes (once passed into law in El Salvador) mean BTC will no longer be legal tender in El Salvador.
Global Tax Implications
What this also means is the BTC will no longer be "foreign currency" under the laws of other nations.
Most nations define "foreign currency" in their tax and other laws as: the legal tender of another nation state.
This has significant tax implications, as most countries do not tax profits or losses on foreign currency transactions unless you are a trader. To do so would cause every foreign currency purchase either while travelling or online, to become a tax event.
Attempting to exclude BTC from the general definition of "foreign currency" in national laws is tricky and problematic because it infringes the Doctrine of Comity: The principle of respecting the sovereignty of foreign countries in relation to their own laws in relation to their citizens and institutions.
Only one other nation state has made BTC legal tender (in April 2022): the Central African Republic (CAF) and they repealed their BTC Legal Tender law in September 2023, likely under IMF pressure.
Other countries such as Panama got close, but were ultimately pressured not to do so.
What this means is that from the date these changes are implemented in El Salvadoran law, Bitcoin will no longer be foreign currency under other nation's tax and other laws.
Why did El Salvador give in the IMF pressure?
It is important to note that El Salvador is not giving up on BTC. It still holds substantial BTC reserves, is mining BTC with volcano power and supports BTC adoption.
However the compulsory aspect of BTC adoption has not been successful. It has not been adopted in practice and the law has not been enforced. Moreover, Bitcoin Libertarians have opposed compulsion from the beginning and the compulsory aspect has not been popular in El Salvador itself.
The Chivo Wallet has been problematic and is highly centralised. Part of the IMF deal is to reduce government involvement in it.
So President Bukele is really just dropping the unsuccessful parts of his Bitcoin strategy while keeping the successful parts. He is a pragmatist.
It was never part of El Salvador's interests to impact the tax treatment of BTC in other countries, and the IMF has obviously been putting a lot of pressure on countries on this issue.
But these changes also mean El Salvador is no longer special regarding BTC, as many nations, including Argentina and soon the US are adopting BTC friendly laws, without making it legal tender.
From this perspective El Salvador will not be as popular a relocation or business investment destination with cryptocurrency enthusiasts and entrepreneurs. This is especially so as El Salvador's laws are super unfriendly to cryptocurrencies other than BTC.
It was BTC Maximalist country.
Please vote for my Hive witness. (KeyChain or HiveSigner)
Lightning is just not a suitable system for a country wide roll out and SPECIFICALLY almost nobody is ready to switch to a Bitcoin standard for daily life. Bitcoin is still a highly volatile asset: great if you're using it as a speculative asset or for savings but not daily commerce.
HBD would have solved this and the forthcoming HBD BTC decentralised pair on @vsc.network coupled with the Lightning Hive gateway will absolutely rock it.
Lets see if all those Western Bitcion influencers will stay. Alot of them have moved there.
El Salvador was likely to face such sanctions. In order to use it as legal tender, they had to reduce their external dependency to zero. They had to wait for major states like the US to legalize BTC.
Hmm I think there have been some pressures from high level positions like ecosoc to force some drop on bitcoin, governments want all centralized and that's the opposite of crypto
Greetings @apshamilton ,
Appreciate this information....thank you for giving us some insight as to what this means for El Salvador.
Happy Christ-mas,
Bleujay
This is informative and unfortunate.
Congratulations @apshamilton! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)
<table><tr><td><img src="https://images.hive.blog/60x70/https://hivebuzz.me/@apshamilton/upvotes.png?202412211946" /><td>You distributed more than 78000 upvotes.<br />Your next target is to reach 79000 upvotes. <p dir="auto"><sub><em>You can view your badges on <a href="https://hivebuzz.me/@apshamilton" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener" title="This link will take you away from hive.blog" class="external_link">your board and compare yourself to others in the <a href="https://hivebuzz.me/ranking" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener" title="This link will take you away from hive.blog" class="external_link">Ranking<br /> <sub><em>If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word <code>STOP